변경 이력
모든 데이터 변경, 정정, 방법론 버전은 여기와 각 기록의 자체 이력에 기록됩니다.
| 날짜 | 대상 | 변경 내용 |
|---|---|---|
| 2026년 10월 16일 | 방법론 v1.7.0 | Owner ruling: the publication threshold of a site is four scored clinics; ten remains the target of the collection gate and fifteen the roster target. A site with four to nine scored clinics is published open to search — ordinary home page, full sitemap — and stays in the re-collection loop until it reaches ten; the holding page with noindex and an empty sitemap is shown only below four. A clinic without a published score is still shown nowhere. Weights, rubrics, the 75% coverage threshold, ceilings and holds are unchanged. |
| 2026년 9월 25일 | 방법론 v1.4.0 | Owner ruling: the 14-day reply window before publication is removed. A negative finding — one official register record about this unit or this person, from the register that governs the claim, with a status in force — is published as soon as it is assembled, with the register's line verbatim, the link and the date of reading; a negative finding is published exactly as fast as a positive one. The same day the register sends the clinic a letter from this site's corrections address; the clinic's reply, when it comes, is shown next to the fact, and the score moves only on a source. An unsent letter never holds or removes a finding. One official record per finding, the governing register, status in force only, the name-match rule and 'an absence is never published' are unchanged; so are the weights, the 75% coverage threshold, ceilings, holds and the ten-clinic floor. |
| 2026년 9월 25일 | 방법론 v1.5.0 | Owner ruling: the register never writes to a clinic on its own initiative — no letters about findings and no letters asking for missing data. Right of reply is passive, as in v1.0: a finding is on the profile in the register's own words, with the link and the date it was read; a clinic that disagrees uses this site's corrections form or corrections address; its reply is shown next to the fact, and the score moves only on a source. Everything else in v1.4 is unchanged. |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | Banobagi Plastic Surgery (바노바기성형외과) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | BK Plastic Surgery (BK성형외과) | axes.M1: 2 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | D&A Plastic Surgery (D&A성형외과) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | Dream Plastic Surgery (드림성형외과) | axes.M7: 2 → 3 (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § B closed lexicon — satisfaction: owner 53) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | Dream Plastic Surgery (드림성형외과) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | ID Hospital (아이디병원) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | JK Plastic Surgery (JK성형외과) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 글로비성형외과의원 (GLOVI Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 노블레스홍인식성형외과의원 (Noblesse Hong In-sik Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 더바디성형외과의원 (The Body Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 방법론 v1.3.0 | Two new reasons for an empty cell: 'register does not cover this class of facility or this territory' (proved by a quote of the register's own statement of coverage; leaves the coverage denominator like a closed register) and 'nothing to query' (the clinic publishes no surname or no legal entity; stays in the denominator). Registers are read per jurisdiction — province, Land, emirate or region — where that is what licenses; openness, closedness and coverage are properties of the register class in that jurisdiction, and a closed jurisdiction never closes the whole country. The country map names sources, access and jurisdictions only; it never changes an anchor. The anchors of M1, M3, M4 and M5 are restated: 5 on M3 and M5 requires the number the clinic itself publishes; a found record whose specialty the register does not confirm is 3, not 1, unless the clinic claims a protected title the register does not show; adjacency is a closed list; a practice registered under its host facility scores 4 on M4. The advertising lexicon (M7) is closed: 2 needs an unconditional absolute about the patient's future safety or the treatment outcome, rendered in the clinic's own voice; purpose clauses, revision programmes, manufacturer warranties and equipment statements are not patterns; absolutes about the past and satisfaction figures are 3. M9 counts a document class only when it is reachable from a stable address and named by a heading or a labelled control. A record is published only if at least one register axis holds a value. Every cell records how it was read (script, second egress, browser) and is re-verified in the same mode; a page that fails to load never degrades a cell. A negative finding needs one official register record about this unit or this person, from the register that governs the claim, with a status in force; the clinic receives a letter and a 14-day reply window before the finding is published; an absence (“no sanctions”, “not found”) is never rendered. Personal identifiers are never stored. Weights, the 75% coverage threshold, ceilings, holds and the ten-clinic floor are unchanged. |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 봉봉성형외과의원 (Bong Bong Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 브이아이피(VIP)성형외과의원 (VIP Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 비에이성형외과의원 (B.A.E. Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 수아이성형외과의원 (SUI Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 오두종성형외과의원 (Oh Doo-jong Plastic Surgery) | axes.M7: 4 → 3 (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § B closed lexicon — satisfaction: owner 53) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 오두종성형외과의원 (Oh Doo-jong Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 이룸성형외과의원 (Illume Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 이미지성형외과의원 (Image Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 일치성형외과의원 (ILCHI Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 정성훈성형외과의원 (Jung Sung-hoon Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 제네시스성형외과의원 (Genesis Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 22일 | 제이더블유(JW)정원성형외과의원 (JW Plastic Surgery) | axes.M1: 5 → null (Methodology v1.3 (owner rulings 2026-09-22) — § C class closed in the record's jurisdiction) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | Banobagi Plastic Surgery (바노바기성형외과) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | BK Plastic Surgery (BK성형외과) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | BK Plastic Surgery (BK성형외과) | axes.M4: null → null (Re-run against HIRA 병원·약국찾기 (v1.2 loop pass 1): five name spellings plus the address and the autocomplete normalisation; no facility record under this name.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | D&A Plastic Surgery (D&A성형외과) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | D&A Plastic Surgery (D&A성형외과) | axes.M9: null → 1 (Re-run: complete presence check over the six pages the clinic site publishes (v1.2 loop pass 1).) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | Dream Plastic Surgery (드림성형외과) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | Dream Plastic Surgery (드림성형외과) | summary: "Multi-physician plastic-surgery clinic in Sinsa-dong, Gangnam-gu. The responsible physician is named as legal representative in the clinic's own site footer and matched in the national specialist-society directory and the facility register with a matching specialist headcount. The clinic's own homepage states an unconditional satisfaction guarantee about surgical safety and results." → "Multi-physician plastic surgery clinic in Sinsa-dong, Gangnam-gu, Seoul. The responsible physician is named as legal representative in the clinic's own site footer and is matched in the national specialist-society directory and in the government facility register, which records a matching plastic-surgery specialist headcount at the address." (Rewritten as neutral patient-facing facts: the previous wording restated the clinic's own promotional claim, which the wording lint rejects; the finding stays on the M7 cell with its exact quote.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | ID Hospital (아이디병원) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | JK Plastic Surgery (JK성형외과) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 글로비성형외과의원 (GLOVI Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 글로비성형외과의원 (GLOVI Plastic Surgery) | axes.M8: null → 3 (Mechanical cross-locale comparison (methodology v1.1, item 9).) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 글로비성형외과의원 (GLOVI Plastic Surgery) | axes.M8: null → 3 (Mechanical cross-locale comparison (methodology v1.1, item 9).) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 노블레스홍인식성형외과의원 (Noblesse Hong In-sik Plastic Surgery) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 더바디성형외과의원 (The Body Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 봉봉성형외과의원 (Bong Bong Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 브이아이피(VIP)성형외과의원 (VIP Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 비에이성형외과의원 (B.A.E. Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 수아이성형외과의원 (SUI Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 오두종성형외과의원 (Oh Doo-jong Plastic Surgery) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 오두종성형외과의원 (Oh Doo-jong Plastic Surgery) | axes.M7: null → 4 (Re-run: the site answers over http (the https port serves an expired self-signed default certificate), so the earlier load failure was a protocol problem, not a dead site; lexicon scan completed and quoted (v1.2 loop pass 1).) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 오두종성형외과의원 (Oh Doo-jong Plastic Surgery) | contacts.website: "https://www.ohdoojong.co.kr/" → "http://www.ohdoojong.co.kr/" (The clinic serves its site over http; https on this host answers an expired self-signed certificate for an unrelated common name.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 이룸성형외과의원 (Illume Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 이미지성형외과의원 (Image Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 일치성형외과의원 (ILCHI Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 정성훈성형외과의원 (Jung Sung-hoon Plastic Surgery) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 정성훈성형외과의원 (Jung Sung-hoon Plastic Surgery) | axes.M7: null → 3 (Re-run: the site answers over http (the https port serves an expired self-signed default certificate); lexicon scan completed and quoted (v1.2 loop pass 1).) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 정성훈성형외과의원 (Jung Sung-hoon Plastic Surgery) | contacts.website: "https://www.jshps.co.kr/" → "http://www.jshps.co.kr/" (The clinic serves its site over http; https on this host answers an expired self-signed certificate for an unrelated common name.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 제네시스성형외과의원 (Genesis Plastic Surgery) | axes.M3: null → null (Re-run against the medical_licence class (v1.2 loop pass 1): register re-probed, still login-gated; secondary routes run; typed retry → registry_closed.) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 제이더블유(JW)정원성형외과의원 (JW Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection (v1.2 loop pass 1). |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 제이더블유(JW)정원성형외과의원 (JW Plastic Surgery) | axes.M8: null → 3 (Mechanical cross-locale comparison (methodology v1.1, item 9).) |
| 2026년 9월 20일 | 제이더블유(JW)정원성형외과의원 (JW Plastic Surgery) | axes.M8: null → 3 (Mechanical cross-locale comparison (methodology v1.1, item 9).) |
| 2026년 9월 18일 | 방법론 v1.2.0 | Coverage is measured against what the country lets us check: a register class that does not exist here or is closed to machine queries (with the refusal on record) leaves the coverage denominator; a completed query with no match, an attempt that did not complete and a single language front stay in it. A register miss is never a value: the three anchors that used to encode a miss (M1 = 1, M4 = 3, M5 = 1) now mean a found record that contradicts the claim, or, for M4 = 3, a register that is not machine-accessible while the clinic publishes its facility number. Where the specialist register is closed, M1 is not scored on that site at all; what a society, ISAPS or a hospital page says is shown on the profile as a secondary fact outside the score. Commercial mirrors of an official register can support M3–M5 up to 4 with secondary provenance. M8 may be empty only for a single language front or while the clinic site fails to load. The citation verifier applies exactly three normalisations (HTML entities, Unicode NFC, whitespace). Weights, rubrics otherwise, the 75% coverage threshold, ceilings, holds and the ten-clinic floor are unchanged. |
| 2026년 9월 17일 | D&A Plastic Surgery (D&A성형외과) | axes.M8: null → 5 (Mechanical cross-locale comparison (methodology v1.1, item 9).) |
| 2026년 9월 17일 | ID Hospital (아이디병원) | axes.M8: null → 2 (Mechanical cross-locale comparison (methodology v1.1, item 9).) |
| 2026년 9월 17일 | JK Plastic Surgery (JK성형외과) | axes.M8: null → 2 (Mechanical cross-locale comparison (methodology v1.1, item 9).) |
| 2026년 9월 17일 | 방법론 v1.1.0 | Completeness of collection became a build gate. Every cell we could not verify now carries a typed reason (register absent in this country, register not machine-accessible, queried and not found, attempt not completed, single language front) and, where a query was run, the attempt log; a closed register is tried through secondary routes before a cell is left empty; cross-locale consistency (M8) is computed mechanically. Only clinics with a published score are shown; a site publishes only with at least ten scored clinics (target fifteen) and otherwise shows a holding page while collection continues. Home title, heading and description name the country and are built from the site’s own data. Weights, rubrics, the coverage threshold, ceilings and holds are unchanged. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | Banobagi Plastic Surgery (바노바기성형외과) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | BK Plastic Surgery (BK성형외과) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | D&A Plastic Surgery (D&A성형외과) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | Dream Plastic Surgery (드림성형외과) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | ID Hospital (아이디병원) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | JK Plastic Surgery (JK성형외과) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | 노블레스홍인식성형외과의원 (Noblesse Hong In-sik Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | 방법론 v1.0.0 | Initial public methodology: nine mechanical axes (M1–M9, weights summing to 100), 1–5 rubric per axis, weighted composite normalised over axes that hold a value, 75% coverage threshold, hold ladder H1–H3, score caps only from verified-false findings, focus penalty, registry-gated crowns. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | 오두종성형외과의원 (Oh Doo-jong Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | 오두종성형외과의원 (Oh Doo-jong Plastic Surgery) | axes.M7: 4 → null (Citation re-check: quote not found at https://www.ohdoojong.co.kr/ (fetch failed (node + curl): Command failed: curl -sL -A Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 Chrome/128 Safari/537.36 beauty-grid-verifier/1.0 --max-time 20 -w ); cell degraded to could-not-verify.) |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | 정성훈성형외과의원 (Jung Sung-hoon Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection. |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | 정성훈성형외과의원 (Jung Sung-hoon Plastic Surgery) | axes.M7: 3 → null (Citation re-check: quote not found at https://www.jshps.co.kr/ (fetch failed (node + curl): Command failed: curl -sL -A Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 Chrome/128 Safari/537.36 beauty-grid-verifier/1.0 --max-time 20 -w ); cell degraded to could-not-verify.) |
| 2026년 8월 29일 | 제네시스성형외과의원 (Genesis Plastic Surgery) | Initial collection. |